Estate agents appointed to sell Slaley Hall timeshare lodges despite ongoing arbitration

Timeshare Consumer Association
6 min readApr 20, 2022


Slaley hall Lodges: Sellers appointed

Bristol based timeshare company Seasons Holidays accused of foul play by appointing estate agents to sell the lodges, despite arbitration process not having reached conclusion

Seasons Holidays in the media

Seasons have been reported on many times in the last few years, and often for the alleged mistreatment of clients. In November 2020 they were first accused of trying to “push out elderly members” from the Slaley Hall lodges, in what some suspected was an attempt to cash in on the suddenly increased value British holiday accommodation. Several media sources reported on the case, including award winning BBC consumer program You and Yours.

Next, Andrew and Wendy Wilkinson went to the media, claiming Seasons were reneging on a £25,000 deal that was supposed to give their family all year round access to the facilities at Clowance Estate & Country Club. Media picked up on the story, and Seasons ended what Andrew Wilkinson described as a 5 year battle by reinstating the Wilkinsons’ agreed access.

Three months later, Stirlingshire couple Joe and Linda Ashby made national news after revealing that a high pressure sales presentation at a ‘free holiday’ at a Seasons property in Scotland triggered a chain of events which they claimed at the time led to financial devastation. Within 2 years, the Ashbys had lost the timeshare, their home, and were left with a £21,000 debt.

Slaley Hall Lodges

Seasons and their unhappy customers traded blows in the media, with Seasons seemingly determined to sell the Lodges which members had paid to use until 2069. Furious owners have spoken out to media including the BBC and ITV on their frustration with Seasons, and the Hurley family who own the company. Tim Norman, a 53 hotelier from Bridlington and long time Slaley Hall Lodge owner was among many voices accusing the Hurleys of manipulating the club constitution by having their son Jack appointed as an ‘independent’ board member. Jack promptly voted along with his parents on a motion to sell the lodges out from under the club members who had paid to use them for another 47 years.

Clare D’Agostino, who has been coming to SHL. “We all love it. My brother Alan, his wife and son are all golfers and they expected to be enjoying Slaley for the foreseeable future. Alan can not get his head around the fact we may be cheated out of it.

“My 86 year old mum, Vera, is both upset and furious at the injustice of what Seasons are doing. We still can’t work out how it is being allowed to happen. It is so wrong that Seasons can infiltrate the committee and abuse their position to engineer the sale of the lodges. It’s disgraceful, disappointing and upsetting.”

Legal action

The lodge owners story was again taken up by several media outlets and the owners staged a fightback, hiring a legal team.

The Legal Action Group sent the following message to members in April 2022:

Dear member

As you know, on 14 March an arbitration notice regarding the legality of the wind up was issued to a number of Respondents, including Hutchinson Trustees and SHLL.

We expect a legal arbitrator to be appointed in the coming weeks.

As per Clause 26 of the SHOC Constitution, the appointment of the arbitrator should be agreed by the parties involved or, if this is not possible, is appointed by the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators (upon application).

The Legal Action Group.

For sale

Without waiting for the arbitration results however Slaley Hall Lodges have been put up for sale by Hutchinson Trustees.

Hutchinson are believed by many members to be acting in the interest of Seasons Holidays and their associated companies. A flurry of media announced that the lodges are being sold by estate agents Avison Young, although since it became clear that the arbitration process is still ongoing, they have removed listings from Rightmove.

Lodge owners on Facebook are incensed that the lodges are being advertised as for sale while the arbitration process is still ongoing.

Speaking about a media article in which the properties are described as ‘former timeshare lodges’, one owner, CD says “They are not former timeshare lodges we still own our lodges and the club has not wound up so they cannot be sold unencumbered we still have our leases till 2069 and have the certificates to prove it.”

Another owner, HM, said: “They should not be marketing them and I suspect they’re continuing to partly as part of their ongoing intimidate/suppress the masses tactics.”

Tim Norman, himself a long time visitor to Slaley Hall Lodges commented “I would like to see the management company and respondents act professionally and respect the arbitration process.”


Daniel Keating, information officer for the Timeshare Consumer Association (TCA) commented: “We hope that the Slaley Hall Lodge owners are treated fairly and their contracts respected. If anything underhand has happened to subvert the constitution, then we also hope that the person or persons responsible will be brought to justice.”

If you have a timeshare related issue or question, get in touch with the TCA for free, confidential advice.

Timeshare Consumer Association. Contact us on: T: 01908881058 (ask for Daniel), E: (Address to Daniel).

WhatsApp (message only) +447586871055

TCA provides a central resource of consumer information on timeshare matters for the media and other organisations — We work towards encouraging responsible, honest, timeshare operators. We also publicly expose negative consumer practices and organisations which operate in a manner detrimental to timeshare buyers and owners.

An important part of our mission is to lobby UK and European Governments and regulatory bodies for improved consumer protection in the timeshare environment and collect information on frauds and mis-selling, for action by enforcement authorities.

We are staffed by former and current timeshare owners, as well as former timeshare industry staff. We know our way around the timeshare business

Timeshare Consumer Association Newsdesk here

Timeshare Consumer Association on YouTube here

Timeshare Consumer Association on Facebook here

Timeshare Consumer Association on Medium here

Timeshare Consumer Association on LinkedIn here

Timeshare Consumer Association on Quora here

Timeshare Consumer Association website here

We are a proud member of the UK Small Charities Coalition

First published on MyNewsDesk April 2022



Timeshare Consumer Association

Friendly, impartial advice from timeshare experts: owners, ex timeshare owners, even ex timeshare industry insiders